SillyDonut
SillyDonut

IITians not ready to work at ISRO at 5digit monthly salary.

Money is everything?

Isro pays 60k-95k to fresher engineers... Still IITians are not joining.

Slogging for Western Mnc is the only desire of IITians?

Comments and solutions??

https://www.businesstoday.in/latest/story/iitians-not-joining-isro-60-students-walked-out-of-recruitment-drive-after-seeing-pay-structure-s-somanath-401614-2023-10-11

18mo ago
Talking product sense with Ridhi
9 min AI interview5 questions
Round 1 by Grapevine
PeppyMarshmallow
PeppyMarshmallow

Everything is so expensive right now. Is it wrong to think about financial stability.

SillyDonut
SillyDonut
TCS18mo

I met a 2019 passed out IIT Madras guy at Thiruvananthapuram and he was drawing 98k.

He left mnc to pursue isro after getting single digit rank in isro merit list.

It's all about priorities.

80-90k is enough to take care of 5 people family in any metro

PeppyMarshmallow
PeppyMarshmallow

I hope an IIT grad can help us with an answer.

GroovyBoba
GroovyBoba

It's always about the money. IITians be lining outside to get the job of a janitor if being a janitor paid 30l+. With cover letters mentioning how they dream about sweeping the floors clean.

Same is true for everyone else. If ISIS be hiring remote SWEs roles paying 40+l for writing code for rockets then y'all be happily asking for referrals from a bunch of terrorists

QuirkyNugget
QuirkyNugget

Hey hey let's not stretch it to isis and all. It was fine till janitor

BouncyNugget
BouncyNugget

The real question is why prefer IITians. Why isn't the discussion about anyone who wants to join? Hell I'm ready to join for that pay. Pretty sure I won't get in though 😅

GoofyRaccoon
GoofyRaccoon
Student18mo

"Somanath, who is at the top post at ISRO and also the secretary of the Department of Space, was Rs 2.5 lakh - which is the average placement package in top IITs"

We need to stop making an example of sacrifice. Pay talent (and yourself) fairly or you'll see among your talent people to whom sitting on the high horse of self sacrifice is as dear as money

ZoomyTaco
ZoomyTaco

2.5 lakh is just the basic if i remember. You have 42% da 18% hra then 5% ta too

GigglyPretzel
GigglyPretzel

Include HFTs like Tower Research and Graviton Research and everything is blown out of water.

FloatingJellybean
FloatingJellybean

What kind of moral guilty trip is this? We're not in state of emergency where you must stand with nation's services. If ISRO wants top talent, they need to pay for top talent.

FuzzyNarwhal
FuzzyNarwhal
Cred17mo

Exactly. End of discussion. It’s a capitalist world

SwirlySushi
SwirlySushi

Passion is for the privileged which most IITians are not.

TwirlyPotato
TwirlyPotato

I don't blame them and tbh if I were one of them, I'd do the same too.

If we as a country demand first world level income tax from our highest earners and give crumbling infrastructure in return then they will leave.

I know OP will not like what I'm saying but don't blame the players because the rules of the game are rigged. We're poorly run as a country and continually bringing up patriotism is just denying the real issues here.

If we need our best and brightest to stay then we need to look at ourselves and see why they're leaving. Why are we so beholden to the idea that our primary allegiance is to our country, most of everyone here works for multinationals with no boundaries, consumes content from the world over and probably only buys international merchandise. In a capitalistic world, the only allegiance is to yourself and these guys are following the rational outcome of the system that produced them.

So yeah, solutions are there but I don't think we're ready to really rewire ourselves and we'd rather blame the players, not the game or the ones who make the rules.

SillyPretzel
SillyPretzel

Like my girl, Madonna, said: 'cause we're living in a material world 🎶🎶

SqueakyPenguin
SqueakyPenguin
TCS18mo

Aerospace Engineering is way more difficult than CSE hence people prefer going for coding related jobs or do MBA after engineering because it's way too easy compared to do an Master's degree or PhD in Aerospace

ZoomyTaco
ZoomyTaco

There are cse ece jobs in isro too

CosmicPancake
CosmicPancake

People here be quoting "Somnath is getting 2.5lpa" What most people don't realise is what else he and other ISRO employees get from govt. Their kids education is funded by govt, they get vehicle, servants, banglow, bonuses, no medical expenses. Loan at insanely low rate from govt banks, and many other benefits. Let's be honest here a person who is going to IIT has only money as main motivating factor rest everything to them is "what a non IITn would do"

GroovyTaco
GroovyTaco

You should join then

PerkyWalrus
PerkyWalrus
CARS2418mo

After some practical inside grinding -

Most of them, at their first year come with dreaming a job in fancy companies, let this be "X"%, most of these falling under X will somehow attain a job.

Who join IIT for IAS/IES/IPS(UPSC) Still, let this be some "U"%

Students who aspire to pursue higher education in their respective research specialisations are "R"%

MBA folks - "B"%

Students under X (~98% of X) don't look for writing ISRO exam, you knew their motive enough.

B students barely look to this exam (buffering if one or two took this by mistake)

We are left with U & R who can attempt ISRO as they've grip in their respective branch concepts.

Very few from U attempt but if they're qualified they think a lot to join.

Now, R, these will definitely have the motive to work in ISRO if selected, but biggest % of them are fancy for Foreign University tag and cannot join ISRO at the last minute.

For an academic year having ~1000 students: X>>>>>>>B>>>R>U.

Interesting part:

There are 100s of non IIT engineering colleges in India, there are lakhs of students (don't just stop at 9L, assume the highest number you know) and atleast 10k students who pray to work for ISRO, this also includes who are taking another attempt to write for ISRO.

Guess how many IITians are serious about this exam? Very less compared, right?

First year students are attracted by fancy lifestyle as they have studied their assess off to land at IIT.

Go to any IIT couple of years back, ISRO comes in talk only from final or pre final concentrated students.

ISRO was more of a prouder lifestyle than a fancy one.
Consistency of maturity might not be possible to all.

Injecting ISRO dream into a first year student on their induction programme is 1% club, ain't easy.

PerkyWalrus
PerkyWalrus
CARS2418mo

9 years back, my branch was introduced as higher government/civil servants, 4 years down the lane, most of us landed into corporate sector, even those who raised hands for only IES/IAS/UPSC.

8 years later, there are barely freshers who aspire to work in government sector.

Influencing does work in those 4/5 years for career/dream change.

Discover more
Curated from across
Indian Startups
by SillyJellybeanProduct Owner
Top comments
user

We’ll be able to move mountains once we stop obsessing with IITians. They work their asses off to get into IITs to ge...

user

He’s absolutely right. You ask any elite UG student what their northstar is and it’s usually the highest paying job. ...