Should learning a language be made compulsory?
There is an argument that many developed countries use language tests to allow immigration to their country, including USA, UK, Germany etc. Logically, Indian states expecting minimum language learning for leveraging opportunities should be okay, right? PS: I do not endorse violence or political rhetoric in the name of language.
Its not a mandatory by any standards , English is an international language and in Germany it's not mandatory to learn German to practise job etc etc.Some courses however may require German language proficiency but KARNATAKA is NOT A COUNTRY ITS A STATE IN A DEVELOPING COUNTRY.
Native language will only help you blend into the local community,it doesn't really change ANYTHING ON HOW WELL YOU'LL ACE IN YOUR JOB/SKILL.
Please don't drag random trolls of twitter on grapevine.
this “learn Kannada” rift started when northerners started asking the locals to talk in Hindi on the basis of it being national language.
the response is a bit aggressive but they’re not wrong to fight back right?
Would you be fine if bglr is made capital of India just coz someone says it is the start up capital?? There is no sense in it right?
So how would the locals feel if an outsider who is welcomed as a guest tries to impose their language on the locals?
In the image attached please concentrate on “ we’d encourage and respect “ this can go both ways can’t it?
Jo hua vo acha hua. Jo ho raha hai vo bhi acha ho raha hai. aur jo hoga vo bhi DOOSRE STATES/CITIES k liye kafi acha hoga !
bangalore vaise bhi kafi crowded ho gaya hai, and look at other beautiful cities (state capitals) of India !
for eg, Jaipur - it has 50 engineering colleges but all students go to bangalore, pune, mumbai, hyd, gurgaon for job.
Why can't Jaipur get some 10% share of IT companies ? u will find local talent , then we have NIT -jaipur, BITS pilani , IIT Jodhpur , IIM Udaipur !
It has everything what a corporate company will need !
its good that kannadigas are putting those restrictions, if more immigrants come, then for sure u will loose ur culture !
That should be a choice, and not a necessity. People are hired for their skills, and not their willingness to lick ass for local politics. Unless that's what you were hired to do. Then it's kinda okay
USA and Germany are completely different country which asks other nationals to do so.. Karnataka is asking people of the country of which it is a part to do so... Other nation citizens need USA and Germany so they Listen to them.. India does not need Karnataka to tolerate it's tantrums...
Secondly, What Germany and USA does is permissible as per their Laws and regulations .. The day Indian constitution will make such rule then it will depend upon rest of Indians if they want to learn Kannada or not....
"India does not need Karnataka to tolerate it's tantrums" - you deserve the treatment you are getting in karnataka. Entitled ones like you need to get down from your high horses and show a little more humility towards local cultures. And yeah, India absolutely needs Karnataka. You are either really insignificant in the larger scheme to things to have no clue how, or you are probably here to just troll and raise temperatures.
Never been to Karnataka.. So this rant about treatment is futile
Looks like your culture is good enough to produce rickshaw drivers only as I see them only asking everyone to speak Kannada, I am yet to find any Kannada speaking CEO supporting this decision , it's better if you leave intellectual things to "outsiders", maybe even your CM realised same
See more comments
Discover More
Curated from across
Office Gossip on
by GoldenHandcuff
Amazon
Office kalesh over zoom call for using Hindi
https://twitter.com/gharkekalesh/status/1741071082860462379?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw%7Ctwcamp%5Etweetembed%7Ctwterm%5E1741071082860462379%7Ctwgr%5E88a3f9e9222b2bb93376a8a86ca5a80959debcaf%7Ctwcon%5Es1_&ref_url=https%3A%2F%2Fd-43696014520458914.ampproject.net%2F2312012346000%2Fframe.html