FuzzyNugget
FuzzyNugget

Revealing salary in the first round. Yay or nay?

Had the first (exploration) call with my would-be boss and HR lead to figure out which role I would fit in. Company is an MNC startup, best culture ive heard of, lots of friends working there in different verticals etc. I usually dont reveal salary this early on but it was a very quick call and they asked about it and I felt like I had to this time to not come off as a snob or stuck up.

Chances are low and I am okay pushing back but Im paranoid about getting lowballed now. Any advice on how to better my chances in the upcoming rounds? Greatly appreciate any help

16mo ago
Talking product sense with Ridhi
9 min AI interview5 questions
Round 1 by Grapevine
BubblyPotato
BubblyPotato

It depends on where you are in terms of the compensation spectrum. It can definitely lead to bias if your current salary is not on the higher side.

For too long, I have played this back and forth game of revealing salary and asking them for budget and frankly, it’s too tiring in Indian recruitment circles.

So, I have started just being honest from the beginning about my current pay & expectation and have seen recruiters be transparent about their budgets too. Eventually if a company has to lowball they anyway would, but I am glad that I don’t have to exercise so much cognitive effort playing this game of riddles

FuzzyNugget
FuzzyNugget

I have a strong feeling this may work here. Thanks 🙏🏽

FluffyPotato
FluffyPotato

What if I straightup lie and say it to be 25% less than my expected TC.

CosmicLlama
CosmicLlama

To whom I did not reveal my salary, none of them called back.

PrancingWaffle
PrancingWaffle

Its either you or someone else for them .

SwirlyTaco
SwirlyTaco

Yay.

Disclose your current TC and ask for their approved salary range for this role in return. No requisition is approved without an approved salary / band.

If they refuse to share it, push them once more with the explicit statement that its essential for you to know it beforehand so you know how much time, effort and priority you should build in this engagement.

FuzzyNugget
FuzzyNugget

Didnt occur to do this since it happened v quickly. Wish push in the next round

GroovyKoala
GroovyKoala
Eviden16mo

How do you ensure that they simply won't drag down the pay range once they know how much you earn?

BouncyJellybean
BouncyJellybean

Yay. People love transparent people.

Hiding salary shows you are insecure, thus could be a potential pain in ass later.

GroovyKoala
GroovyKoala
Eviden16mo

But revealing it gives them the power to lowball. What about that?

FuzzyNugget
FuzzyNugget

Exactly what I wanted to avoid. Their culture also seems like one which appreciates this hence I felt v comfortable sharing it

SquishyQuokka
SquishyQuokka
Gojek16mo

Don’t worry about it. The only one to lose is the one who’s more desperate.

FuzzyNugget
FuzzyNugget

Thank you 🙏🏽

MagicalQuokka
MagicalQuokka

Nay, too many people do this and regret it later when they get the lowballed offer

CosmicDumpling
CosmicDumpling

It isnt about lowballing. In a country where you have billions of people, its easy to get someone else. Its always better to discuss about the salary in the first call for quicker closure, either they would take it forward because they have the budget or close it there itself because they dont ( usually folks dont call back if you arent in budget )

ZoomyLlama
ZoomyLlama
TCS16mo

If someone's current salary is very low as compared to market standards for the profile and looking to switch. Then should he tell his expectations if asked?

SwirlyBoba
SwirlyBoba

Telling expectations is ok. Telling low ctc will be a bad move. Lie if asked about previous ctc ! (But never in written)

QuirkyDumpling
QuirkyDumpling
MSCI16mo

I don't think there is anything you can do now given you have already told them your salary, and ideally you had to at some point.

So rather, i would suggest just do some thorough research here and on fishbowl with peers in same company and designation about what range to expect. That way you know what is the ideal range, and if they come back with lowballed offer, you can make a point that it seems too low as per what you know of company standards without taking any names.

In Investment banking, i dont think it can ever work if i don't reveal my salary in the first call from HR to understand the match for profile, and no matter how much you ask, they won't tell you their range.

So the only option is what i said above, research and find from peers.

FuzzyNugget
FuzzyNugget

🙏🏽 thank you very much

DizzyLlama
DizzyLlama
Atlys16mo

If you say this is the best culture company you have heard of, I think it should be fine. Don't worry about it

FuzzyNugget
FuzzyNugget

My thoughts right now. Thanks!!

Discover more
Curated from across
Personal Finance
by WigglyLlamaProduct Marketing Manager

Is this a good way to negotiate expected CTC?

An example scenario: Let’s say my CTC is 34 LPA + annual stock payout of 5 Lakhs. My total yearly earning potential is 39 LPA.

In the new role they don’t have a variable or stocks. Is it reasonable to ask for a 25% hike on the overall ...

Office Gossip
by DerpyDumplingConsultant

How to avoid disclosing current salary

Currently in talks with the CEO of a small international startup (less than 10 total members spread across 4 countries). My existing profile is an exact match for what they are looking for in a candidate (they are implementation partners...

Top comment
user

Are you currently employed? If yes, here's what you can do: Assume you are at 100 and you need 200 and you need ...

Product Managers
by ZestyMarshmallowProduct Manager

(Urgent)Average salary for APM role

I have an offer from a firm where they have mentioned that their current apm has a payscale of 8-9.

Isn't that a bit too low?

I saw a report by the product folks group where they collected 550 data points & found the avg salary to be a...

Business Roles
by QuirkyDumplingQuantitative Research

How does salary negotiation before offer work

I have given interviews and cleared them. I got a call from HR asking for payslips and another offer details.

They said they will get back with offer.

How to go about here? If they come with a lower offer than what i asked, how mu...

Top comment
user

Don't share payslips yet if possible. Do it after finalising your offer details. What information have you share...