BubblyWaffle
BubblyWaffle

Monetising Mentorship 1:1

What are your views in products like topmate, mentorly etc.

See a number of people putting links for 1:1 consultation through topmate where mentor gets paid for thier 'knowledge'.

Has anyone signed up as a mentor or taken anything through so these mentors.

13mo ago
Talking product sense with Ridhi
9 min AI interview5 questions
Round 1 by Grapevine
SquishyBanana
SquishyBanana

I’m divided on this , Mentorship should be free but yeah mentor’s time is precious too. So maybe don’t charge too much . I haven’t tried these platforms though but yes mentorship can be helpful if mentor-mentee relationship is compatible .

BubblyWaffle
BubblyWaffle

What is 'too much' in your view @TepidFanny11

Who decides and how to decide. I have been seeing some 2 year Olds putting 5000 INR for a 1 hour call.

SquishyBanana
SquishyBanana

5000/hr is definitely too much. I would say anything above 500-1000 per hour is too much..

CosmicLlama
CosmicLlama

Paid mentorship is non sense. It like hiring a prostitute to experience married life. Mentorship works best when there is mutual benefit. You help your potential "mentor" first. That "mentor" is happy with you and rewards you with his "mentoring", in turn you help in more. Its best when there is a quid pro quo. A good example is visiting a doctor, if you do not know him and you consulting is thru the "fees" paid. He will treat he symptoms and that's it. Whereas if you are a friend for him, where you can meet him/her at any time/ any place , and The doctor talks to you without expecting fees from you, that treatment will be different. The doctor will look beyond your symptoms, he will really think on figuring out what is ailing you.

These mentors in Topmate as the mentioning equivalent of Fin- influencers. Rembemer that Guy who come when you are watching youtube? he will each you how to make 1cr a year, help you buy your Ferrari? Its him equivalent.

DancingBurrito
DancingBurrito

I’m laughing as I see a consultant write this.

ZippyPanda
ZippyPanda
Cred13mo

Just people trying to make more money at any cost Saw some folks on LinkedIn starting some initiative of free TopMate to help people in need Not sure if it picked up though or not

FluffyBanana
FluffyBanana

Looking for the right mentor? Fill out this form, and we’ll gladly help you grow: https://docs.google.com/forms/d/e/1FAIpQLSfCd9Ujk_pH7gkDxy93hJKfuvsAmQgB7Gl9GgdgYs4Iyz20AA/viewform

Let’s unlock your potential together!

DizzyLlama
DizzyLlama

From topmate? No!

Have I paid for community that gives really good insights? Yes! A lot of money!

SwirlyBoba
SwirlyBoba

Bad idea. The essential idea behind mentorship is to give back and people who are primarily in it for making money end up harming the ecosystem as they try to become much more visible. How do Ankur Warikko and Dev Gadhvi appear on YouTube ?

BubblyPretzel
BubblyPretzel

Check out https://pearmock.com We think we have the right mix of paid-free mentorship options which helps everyone in the community.

SillyJellybean
SillyJellybean

There are multiple problems with stuff like this. There's no market rate or standard, people don't know if what they're going for is even worth it.

Seemed like a decent idea initially but I don't see it working out much long term. Plus people will just approach the person directly and ask to pay instead of going through platform if they even need regular bookings.

PeppyDonut
PeppyDonut
Upgrad13mo

Nobody will work for you at this rate unless untill you have substandard life coaches and expectation is bare minimum. In era of Google search and chat gpt generic coaching won't work

PeppyDonut
PeppyDonut
Upgrad13mo

500-1000 won't make it scalable. Need a minimum of 5000 bucks to make it work. It has to be luxury product or service.

Discover more
Curated from across
Product Managers
by WigglyNarwhalPine Labs

Product survey on Topmate.io

Hi folks, I'm doing a product teardown on Topmate.io and wanted to understand some things from someone who is either a creator there or has taken a session there.

  1. What advantage do you think it offers over its competitors? (Ex - ADPl...
Misc
Misc19mo
by JazzyWalrusSoftware Engineer

Tech influencers selling mentorships on topmate

I see so many LinkedIn Tech influencers selling mentorships on topmate. While this is certainly not wrong. But some are charging 6k for 30 min or so, which is insane. Usually people under 2 years of exp are falling for this. Funny thing ...

Software Engineers
by WigglyRaccoonGoogle

Just hate the topmate

The platform has made every intern a Leadership coach; charging ₹2999/- for each session.

The platform should have at least some decency to verify who is trying to become a mentor.

Top comment
user

It is like only fans for professionals without the skin