MagicalMarshmallow
MagicalMarshmallow

Are design systems overrated?

How many of you are using it in your company?

10mo ago
Talking product sense with Ridhi
9 min AI interview5 questions
Round 1 by Grapevine
PrancingSushi
PrancingSushi

In my experience a proper design system increases productivity

MagicalMarshmallow
MagicalMarshmallow

Thanks for the reply. May I know in what kind of projects you have used design system ? Or can you mention your company name so that I will get an idea

PrancingSushi
PrancingSushi

In mobile app the content of the app doesn’t matter. If the design system is well defined I can use those design token and it’s just plug and play for things like fonts, spacing, themes. It makes it easy to change the theme of the entire app by just modifying the files where colors are defined. Similarly it is easy to make modifications that reflect app wide

SparklyUnicorn
SparklyUnicorn

They are necessary to save time and keep things streamlined. It will only make your work easier.

MagicalMarshmallow
MagicalMarshmallow

Necessary? I don't think so, it depends upon the scope of the project right? I'm talking from a designer's perspective.... Sometimes building a DS is time consuming. For developers..yes it helps a lot

SparklyUnicorn
SparklyUnicorn

I agree with you! For small projects like landing pages and stuff it is not really necessary. I'm a designer too and when you start working on designing a product ( that you're gonna keep working on for a long time) it's really time saving right??

ZestySushi
ZestySushi
Tide10mo

Yes.. they are bit overrated these days. This is coming who has built 3 Design systems for small, medium and working in big team.

Tho I have special niche in Design system. I don’t recommend much to early stage designers.

It more about managerial and governance skills, less about design skills.

Stick to core problem solving as much as you can. It def can be bonus advantage in resume but nothing concrete.

With new AI and automation, this will the first thing that will vanish from design.

I am currently consulting a startup which can a basic level DS in just few clicks with code πŸ˜‚

Killing my own with my own hands πŸ˜‚πŸ˜‚

MagicalMarshmallow
MagicalMarshmallow

Oh God πŸ˜‚. Which company is that? Can u share the website link?

ZestySushi
ZestySushi
Tide10mo

Figrrr

JazzyBoba
JazzyBoba

They are not overrated. They are good to have. It's the refusal of some devs to stick to it is what causes issues and gives them a bad name

MagicalMarshmallow
MagicalMarshmallow

Are u a developer or a designer?

JazzyBoba
JazzyBoba

Dev, now architect

GoofyPotato
GoofyPotato

In a small team trying to find PMF, where the product itself isn't stable, design systems is not necessary. But as you grow and become more complex, they become a necessity

MagicalMarshmallow
MagicalMarshmallow

Agreed to your first point.

GoofyPotato
GoofyPotato

For the second point, when you reach a level where multiple designers are trying to stretch the app with their own creativity, you need a common language for both design and development in order to scale better.

ZestySushi
ZestySushi
Tide10mo

Small MVP is ready, far from something I visioned

MagicalMarshmallow
MagicalMarshmallow

Are you designing a DS for that? πŸ˜…

ZestySushi
ZestySushi
Tide10mo

No, DS for that πŸ˜‚πŸ˜‚

TwirlyPenguin
TwirlyPenguin

average landing page designer ?

i work at a series b startup, just about 2 yoe now. we have 3x B2B applications and the previous designer had fucked up the entire design files and documentation with different components all over the place.

i tried brushing it off and not making an effort for a couple months and it just become too complex to handle with multiple feature implementations coming in.

finally took an entire month to compile all possible flows and really just creating a ds, separate for all applications- made my work so much easier, and the components are even uniform in style and interactions so our users always feel comfortable and within knowledge of use. thats why ds are important.

what i understood is- at some point, you'll want to have keep things Lego style and plug and play. and when there's something new, just build using existing blocks!

MagicalMarshmallow
MagicalMarshmallow

Thanks for sharing your experience. How do you start creating a design system? Do you build from scratch or take any well designed existing design system and alter it as per your needs?

and why did you asked "average landing page designer?" Didn't get you

TwirlyPenguin
TwirlyPenguin

just plain old atomic design. create a map of user flows, keep track of recurring components, create atoms and molecules, use them to create the organism components used in the applications. i took dedicated time off the week to rebuild each flow, adding to the ds. even sat with devs to help them create the components. its still a wip, but definitely sped up work, + easier development for front-end even.

ZippyMochi
ZippyMochi

Nah, they're not over rated. As long as it's not over done, a DS can help give a level of consistency across your products. It's very helpful for complex products and companies with multiple products as well. But the key is to define just the baseline but still let the designers of each product have some level of creativity.

MagicalMarshmallow
MagicalMarshmallow

πŸ‘

SparklyNarwhal
SparklyNarwhal

For a second I thought you were talking about system design.

MagicalMarshmallow
MagicalMarshmallow

Nah bruhπŸ˜…

PerkyDumpling
PerkyDumpling

If anything they are underrated in real job.

Discover more
Curated from across
Designers
by QuirkyPretzelUX Designer

Does design system kill creativity in the long run?

We built a very scalable design system for web and mobile app (Has B2B & B2C angle). But after a point I feel it's restricting the creativity especially for certain celebratory/sad events. Sure we can tweak the design system create varia...

Designers
by ZoomyKoalaUI/UX Designer

Are we Designers Obsessed with Figma?

In startup and mid-level companies, single designers often spend more time on developing design systems, exploring Figma's new features, and adapting to its yearly updates rather than focusing on essential tasks.

Software Engineers
by WigglyDumplingRazorpay

Razorpay Frontend - More like a copy paste ninja job

Off late, the frontend engineering at Razorpay has become more of a data entry job. The design system (god knows how many years it will take to be completely ready) is restricting both the devs and the designers a LOT. Designers are lite...

Top comments
user

Ah this is why I hang around here. Thanks for the sauce

user

Hello. Senior FE at Razorpay. Not from the Blade team though. Since not everyone in the comments has all the context,...

user

This is my estimation and I could be wrong. Also I’m in a hurry so it’s not we’ll articulated - A couple years a...