ZippyMochi
ZippyMochi

Should there be a Union of startup and tech employees?

Looks like you can't register a union unless you're employed by a certain company. Self employed people can't register unions.

But it is okay to create unregistered/unofficial unions which don't have any legal right to create contracts or mediate between employees and companies.

I guess an unofficial one could still organize strikes, come up with guidelines/rules for companies and do advocacy for employees.

https://www.legalwindow.in/how-to-register-a-trade-union-in-india/

Might as well keep it unofficial, unregistered and informal. No legal, monetary or taxation hassle. Could even be anonymous leadership/members maybe đź‘€

What do you think?

5mo ago
ZippyMochi
ZippyMochi

@JadeArgent @Elon_Musk @salt thoughts?

SquishyQuokka
SquishyQuokka

I think this is a bad idea

It won't work in India. There will always be greedy companies to exploit you and tons of desperate people willing to work in sub par conditions. Laws and policies need to be improved but that won't happen.

CosmicLlama
CosmicLlama

Forming a Union is. by far the stupidest idea to come out tech industry. If any friends who work in maruti/Hyundai or any teir 1 suppoer ask them about their work culture in factories. Not officers, factory shop floor employees.

Tech people think since they wear a tie and send emails they are officer employees. No you are not. They are the blue collar shop floor workers of the tech Industry .

ZippyMochi
ZippyMochi

But blue collar workers have their unions as well. White collar workers mostly don't.

ZoomyMochi
ZoomyMochi

Always wanted to know - why doesn’t this exist already? Is there a legal restriction or just lack of motivation?

ZippyMochi
ZippyMochi

That's what I'm wondering too. Seems like you need to work in a company to be able to register a union for that company's employees or people working in that particular domain/sector.

That by itself is difficult for employees since no one will want to argue with their bosses and risk getting laid off.

Which is why I think there possibly needs to be an informal union of sorts. Something that doesn't need to get registered, hence it will not be liable for suing or legal action. Companies and police/law will find it very difficult to deal with anonymous organisations especially.

ZoomyMochi
ZoomyMochi

Interesting, thanks for explaining

We need a legal expert!

Discover more
Curated from across
Indian Startups
by GroovyNoodleProduct Manager

We need more Labour Unions in India.

As we're all seeing the levels of injustice in the workplaces all accross the country, with useless laws and BS working hours limits. I think we need more and more labour unions fighting these injustices. How do you think this can come t...

Layoffs
by QuirkyWaffleSoftware Engineer

[Layoffs] Why have we just collectively decided to suck it up rather than retaliate?

It's infuriating how everyone's advice to deal with layoffs is side hustles, wasting your life away to constantly upskill and reducing spending. Basically everyone here is saying "live life like shit to appease your corporate overlords" ...

Top comment
user

You know what you are suggesting? Unions! Simple fact. Organised effort always has higher bargaining power ...

Indian Startups
by SillyJellybeanProduct Owner

POSH unenforced by HR

Came to know of a case where HR tried to quash a serious POSH complaint. Tried to blame the victim instead of handling the case properly.

Victim was forced to file police complaint, even then HR was just looking for reasons to fire so t...